Lincoln International expects deal-by-deal structures will become increasingly common in Europe in the coming years. This would match the growth of the model in the U.S. where research by Co-Investment Partners indicates that such structures account for 25% of deals.
The emergence of this trend is underpinned by several factors:
|
1 |
A deal-by-deal approach allows a financial sponsor to match the capital commitment and structure to the opportunity under consideration. Unconstrained by the inflexible terms of a fund that could have been marketed five or more years prior, a financial sponsor can provide a tailored solution for a specific situation. This approach can tackle issues relating to capital structure, terms and timing that traditional PE firms prefer to avoid. In a market where the cost and availability of debt financing hinders the ability of limited funds to invest, a deal-by-deal sponsor can create a bespoke and actionable solution for selling shareholders.
Ed Cottrell, Partner at Bay Tree Private Equity, explained the benefits of the model “as an alignment of the interests of all key parties at the time of the deal for the benefit of all, including investment term, risk-adjusted return, commitment to the specifics of a deal (not just a wider mandate), deal risks and often the provision of sector and business model expertise including from the LPs.” |
|
2 |
Many sponsors are attracted to the return profile of an opportunity but are sometimes unable to commit to a transaction due to the timing of a fundraising process. Near the end of a fund’s lifecycle, a financial sponsor can be capital constrained. Conversely, in the early months of a new fund, a sponsor may want to pursue a certain type of deal to kick off a fund. Recently, Lincoln has observed some financial sponsors decline opportunities due to fund timing or wanting to have a “statement” first deal in a new fund. |
|
3 |
A deal-by-deal structure aligns incentives between investors, the general partner (GP) and management teams in a much more intimate way than that offered by a traditional PE fund. Stakeholders aligned on a company’s business plan can think big, make bold decisions and have the peace of mind to deliver on the business plan without the fear of a GP exiting an investment “early” to mark a return or due to wider fund-related issues. |
|
4 |
Financial sponsors utilizing the traditional fund structure are already increasingly using co-investment from LPs. A significant pool of capital is available to sponsors with strong track records. Since LPs often all but demand to be given co-invest allocation in a traditional fund structure, it can be easier to move towards a deal-by-deal funding model where LPs can select the individual investments in which they want to deploy capital. |
|
5 |
In a traditional fund structure, fees are charged at usually 2% of committed capital. In a slow deal environment, investors can be charged a significant portion of their funds before any investment of their committed capital is made. Conversely, in a deal-by-deal structure, investors are only charged fees for the duration of their investment, often via a monitoring fee paid by the target. A deal-by-deal structure avoids a situation where a sponsor raises a fund but does not deploy some of the capital for many years, whilst still generating fees on the undeployed capital. The deal-by-deal structure therefore provides a preferable fee structure for investors. |
|
6 |
The special-purpose acquisition company (SPAC) market, notably popular in the U.S. prior to 2022, did not take off with the same vigor in Europe. The complexities of public transactions and associated obligations put off several European investors. Investing in private targets without taking them public – as an alternative to a SPAC – though the deal-by-deal structure has administrative benefits and avoids the disclosure and regulatory burdens of the public markets. |
|
7 |
The challenge from sellers – that deal-by-deal funds have less certainty over funding – is becoming less of an issue due to the increasing sophistication and number of these funds. The deal-by-deal approach is growing increasingly competitive with drawdown times comparable with traditional PE. Funds utilizing the structure have become professionalized in their approach to fundraising for a specific asset. Many firms work with the same investors on a regular basis and as these relationships mature, the positive returns and experience will likely result in more willingness to commit to deal-by-deal funds. |
Lincoln’s Financial Sponsors Group has experience advising across a range of private capital structures and is keen to meet with financial sponsors pursuing this strategy or considering it.
Contributor
Meet Professionals with Complementary Expertise
I strive to develop meaningful, trusting, personal and mutually beneficial relationships with our clients.
Curt Tatham
Managing Director & Co-head of FSG
Chicago
Related Perspectives
Recent Transactions with Private Equity Clients in Europe
Art of the Deal-by-Deal Fund
Deal-by-deal investing has become an increasingly popular strategy for financial sponsors in Europe. Unlike the traditional private equity (PE) approach of raising a fund and deploying it over the course… Read More
Just Food | Humanization in Pet Food Bounds Along Amid Premium-Led Growth
Originally published by JustFood on December 6, 2022 Alex Masters, Managing Director in Lincoln’s Consumer Group, shares current growth drivers he is seeing in the pet food sector and expectations… Read More
Private Equity Investors Are Split on M&A Outlook for 2023
Respondents suggest deal volume would be up – but does data match the mood? In a recent Lincoln survey of over 350 senior private equity professionals, 46% expect 2023 deal… Read More
Promising M&A Outlook for Frozen Food Companies
Frozen foods have seen notable growth since 2019 as a result of shifting consumer behavior. Strong sales have enabled more efficiencies at scale, but some companies also face capacity constraints… Read More
Global Supply Chain Volatility: 2022 Outlook
Amidst historic production disruption, shortages and low levels of inventory, manufacturers, distributors and retailers have been adapting business strategy real-time in response to continued volatility. There has been a rising… Read More
Adopting Alternative Strategies – How Partnering Expertise Can Help
Company leaders around the globe are facing uncertain business conditions, including geopolitical tensions, inflation, continuing supply chain problems and raw materials shortages. Economies are only just beginning to recover from… Read More
Material Handling Automation: Investment Opportunities for 2022 and Beyond
Catalyzed by substantial e-commerce growth and more and larger fulfillment and distribution centers being built around the globe, 2021 brought increased investor interest in the material handling automation sector. A… Read More
M&A Trends in Japan: Q&A with Director Kenji Uemura
Lincoln International recently welcomed Kenji Uemura, a Tokyo-based Director, to the firm. With unique experience heading the India-Japan mergers and acquisitions (M&A) business in Mumbai and his extensive work in… Read More
Business Leaders Adjust Investment Strategy in Light of CO2 Emissions Standards
As governments and company stakeholders continue to increase their focus on reducing emissions, the shift from fossil fuels to green energy is shaking up almost every sector—resulting in energy efficiency… Read More
Private Equity Pursues Investments in Engineering and Manufacturing Software Sector
Engineering, simulation and manufacturing software is in high demand as companies across industries shift toward digitizing processes. From the early stages of product design and simulation to manufacturing and usage… Read More
GoingPublic | Germany’s M&A Outlook
Originally published by goingpublic on March 10, 2022. Dr. Michael Drill, CEO Germany at Lincoln International, shares insights on current situation of the country’s M&A activity amidst the global economic… Read More
Long-Term Trends Underpinning Utility Services M&A
Investor interest in utility services will remain high given the numerous attractive tailwinds that underpin the sector’s resiliency and growth potential. For telecom, power, gas and water/wastewater, regulatory and public… Read More
Growing Local & Global Private Equity Interest in French Technology
The technology ecosystem in France is booming. In 2021 alone, French startups raised more than €10 billion in venture capital financing, a 2x increase over 2020. To date, the number… Read More
M&A Activity Remains Strong for Companies Supporting Employer-Sponsored Health Benefits
Employer-sponsored, self-funded medical plans have grown in popularity since the implementation of ERISA in the 1970s and now cover nearly two-thirds of all employees and one-third of all Americans. Medical… Read More
While Automotive Supply Chain Headaches Drag On, Buyers & Sellers Prepare for a Busy Year of Dealmaking in 2022
Automakers and suppliers were forced to cope with unique supply chain challenges in 2021, driving significant disruption to production and resulting in levels of inventory at unseen historic lows. These… Read More
Data Center Download: Accelerating Growth, Record Interest in the Space and Transformational Opportunities
Our world has become more reliant than ever on data. As technological innovation stretches from the smartphones in our pockets to wearables, self-driving cars, cloud computing, artificial intelligence, Industry 4.0… Read More
Scrip | What Does 2022 Hold For Biopharma?
Originally published by SCRIP on February 8 , 2022. James West, Director in Lincoln’s Healthcare Group shares that there has been increased private equity firm’s interest in the Biopharma space and… Read More
The Nordic Private Debt Landscape: Strong Growth Projections for Year Ahead
The Nordic region has bounced back stronger than its European counterparts following the COVID-19 pandemic. The gross domestic product (GDP) has largely recovered from a less significant pandemic downturn, whereas… Read More
Will Private Equity Activity in 2022 be as Robust as 2021?
Private equity (PE) has proven to be both stable and even resilient, despite economic uncertainty, as illustrated during the 2008 global financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic. During both events,… Read More
Animal Health Players Pursue Vertical Integration as a Path to Growth
Animal health businesses that have established a strong presence within their area of expertise, may be considering where the next best path to growth lies. While cross-border expansion and consolidation… Read More
M&A Review | Outlook for the German M&A Market in 2022
Originally published by M&A Review on September 6, 2021. The boom in mergers and acquisitions continues! Since the beginning of the year, the global mergers and acquisitions (M&A) business has… Read More
E-commerce, Sustainability and Digital Capabilities Drive Consolidation
Following a rebound in the first half of 2021, the outlook for the economy remains positive for the second half of the year as vaccination rates continue to climb and… Read More
Our Economy Runs on Digital: Fueling Infrastructure Software Investment
As companies continue to move to the cloud and provide high-quality, global-scale cloud solutions, infrastructure software has seen a material increase in investment and consolidation, as evidenced by recent sponsor-led… Read More
Fleet, Field and Asset Management Software: Convergence Creates Investment Opportunities
Maintaining equipment, vehicles and other assets while also optimizing performance of employees and the work they do is a daunting task for any organization. To address this challenge, both large… Read More
Q&A with Lincoln TMT Managing Director Don More: Hacking Cybersecurity Investment
Lincoln International recently welcomed Don More as Managing Director focused on Cybersecurity on the Technology, Media & Telecom team. Don brings to Lincoln 20+ years of deal experience in cybersecurity,… Read More